Perfectly Sustainable earns commissions from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Commissions do not decide which products we recommend or reject. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
The usual mistake with sustainable shoes is judging the pair by its upper. A recycled knit looks like the whole story, yet the foam, rubber, glue and factory work sit underneath it, and a pair that falls apart in a year has to be made all over again.
So we looked for two things in each of the eight pairs below: materials stated clearly enough to check, and buyer reports that suggest a long life. We did not wear or test these shoes. Everything here comes from brand pages, Amazon listings and customer reviews. No pair meets every test, and we say where each one falls short.
Our Picks at a Glance
Our pick
Best for
Key detail
- 1Teva Hurricane XLT2Best forSummer walking, day hikes, wet groundKey detailRecycled REPREVE straps, strong durability reports
- 2Birkenstock ArizonaBest forDaily sandals with a cork footbedKey detailCork and latex footbed, EVA outsole
- 3Veja EsplarBest forA plain white sneaker for work and weekendsKey detailAmazonian rubber in the sole, calfskin upper
- 4Allbirds Tree RunnerBest forWalking and long days on your feetKey detailLyocell upper, sugarcane EVA, washable
- 5Sanuk HempBest forCasual summer wearKey detailHemp cotton upper, 53% recycled outsole
- 6Vivobarefoot PrimusBest forPeople who already like thin solesKey detail85% recycled PET upper, repair and take-back
- 7TOMS AlpargataBest forLight wear and summer outfitsKey detail50% recycled cotton, part-recycled insole
- 8Rothy’s Daily DriverBest forSmart work outfits, machine washingKey detailRecycled bottle thread, machine washable
Key Takeaways
- Shoes are built from many parts, so one recycled material does not make a whole shoe sustainable.
- Long use is one of the biggest things you control. Buy a type you will wear often, and check reports of early failure.
- Each of these eight pairs has at least one synthetic part, and no listing gives a recycled share for every part.
Why the Upper Tells You So Little
An MIT-led lifecycle study of running shoes found about 30 pounds of carbon dioxide per pair, with more than two-thirds of the impact coming from manufacturing, not from the materials. The study is from 2013 and covers running shoes, so treat it as a guide to where the impact sits, not as a figure for these eight pairs.
What to check
- Read every part: upper, lining, footbed, midsole, outsole.
- Look for a percentage next to the word “recycled”.
- Search reviews for “peeling”, “sole” and “months”.
- Ask if the footbed, laces or sole can be replaced.
What the MIT study counted
65
Separate parts in a typical pair
360+
Processing steps to assemble it
2/3+
Share of impact that can come from manufacturing
A shoe bought less often avoids that whole manufacturing run, which is why we put the durability record ahead of the material list. It fits the same logic as a wardrobe without overbuying: the greenest option is often the pair you already own, as long as it still protects your feet. For the fibres themselves, sustainable fabrics compared sets out how hemp, cotton and synthetics differ.
The Pair Least Likely to Be Replaced Soon

Our pick · Long-life sandal
Teva Men’s Hurricane XLT2 Sport Sandal
Early replacement is the failure this sandal seems to avoid. The straps are quick-dry webbing made with traceable REPREVE recycled polyester, the part of the shoe you see and touch most.
The recycled claim stops there. The listing describes an EVA footbed, a nylon shank and a rubber outsole, with no recycled share given for any of them.
Good fit for
- Hot climates and wet trails
- Wearers who keep one pair for years
- Adjusting the fit through the day
- Trips where one pair must do a lot
Not a good fit for
- Offices and cold weather
- A low-plastic shoe
- Anyone who dislikes hook-and-loop closures
- People who want a buckle
Owners talk about years, not months. One wearer gets about five years from a pair and has worn the design for more than 25. Another says theirs still look new after two and a half years, and a third has just finished a six-day bike trek in a third pair.
That record is the case for it. With 11,228 ratings at 4.5, this is one of the larger samples here, and durability comes up without prompting.
Complaints are smaller and mostly about taste. One long-time owner misses the older buckle. Another felt that one of the versions they owned was less well built than the first, so a long history does not guarantee every version will match it.
Verdict
Teva Hurricane XLT2
Choose it if
You want warm-weather shoes that the record suggests will stay in use for several seasons.
Skip it if
Your idea of a sustainable shoe rules out foam and synthetic webbing altogether.
Based on the brand’s product details, the Amazon listing and Amazon customer reviews, checked in November 2026.
A Cork Footbed, if You Pick the Right Upper

Our pick · Natural footbed
Birkenstock Arizona Soft Footbed Sandal
One Amazon page sells several very different shoes here. Suede and oiled leather sit next to Birko-Flor, which is a synthetic upper, so read the colour name before you buy.
The footbed is the shared story. Birkenstock’s product page describes cork from the bark of the cork oak with a latex foam cushion. The outsole is EVA, so the sandal is not plastic-free either.
Good fit for
- Wearers ready for a break-in period
- High arches
- Choosing leather over synthetics
- Warm days around town
Not a good fit for
- Buying without checking the colour name
- Vegan buyers choosing suede
- First-time buyers unsure of width
- Long hikes
With 27,290 ratings at 4.5, this sample is the largest we read, and long use is its main theme. One owner got nine years from a previous pair and still wears them for yard work. Others report keeping older pairs in use for different jobs.
Sizing causes the most trouble, because the listing uses European sizes and two width groups. One buyer found the regular width too wide, returned the pair, and suggests trying them on in a store first.
Not everyone reports the same life. One buyer replaces theirs every year, and another was surprised to receive Birko-Flor after assuming suede.
Verdict
Birkenstock Arizona
Choose it if
You can use a pair for years, and you are comfortable with a leather upper.
Skip it if
You want a shoe with no animal material, unless you pick a synthetic upper knowingly.
Based on the brand’s product details, the Amazon listing and Amazon customer reviews, checked in November 2026.
The Clearest Supply Story in a Leather Sneaker

Our pick · Everyday leather
Veja Men’s Esplar Sneakers
Compared with the two sandals above, this is a closed shoe that suits an office. The listing names a sole of Amazonian rubber, rice waste and recycled rubber, and a lining of cotton and recycled bottles.
Veja says half of its soles are Amazonian rubber, buys from more than 2,500 tapper families, and uses tanneries rated Gold by the Leather Working Group. The upper is still calfskin.
Good fit for
- Offices with a casual dress code
- Long-term wear after a break-in
- People who like supply details they can read
- A clean, simple look
- Standing at work all day
Not a good fit for
- Vegan buyers
- Comfort on the first day
- Thick cushioning
- Soft, supple leather
Stiffness is the honest first report. Several owners needed a few wears before the shoe felt right, and one still found the leather harder than other Veja models and moved them to work days.
Past that stage the comments improve. One buyer on their feet all day says their feet were fine after walking New York for hours. Another family wore them across Europe.
Reports on width disagree. Some call them narrow, while one wide-footed buyer who found the Campo too tight says these fit well. It holds 4.4 from 178 ratings, a small sample compared with most here.
Verdict
Veja Esplar
Choose it if
A leather sneaker suits your work, and you will give it a few weeks to soften.
Skip it if
You expect cushioned comfort straight out of the box.
Based on the brand’s product details, the Amazon listing and Amazon customer reviews, checked in November 2026.
Plant-Based and Light, With a Durability Question

Our pick · Light everyday
Allbirds Men’s Tree Runner
You may trade some durability for a light shoe with plant-derived parts. Allbirds lists a eucalyptus lyocell and recycled polyester upper, a sugarcane-based EVA midsole, and laces from recycled bottles.
Notice the words “based” and “blend”. They mean the shoe is not fully plant-based, and the page does not give a percentage for every part. Machine washing is allowed, which helps it stay wearable.
Good fit for
- City walking and travel days
- Warm feet and breathable uppers
- Wearers who like washing their shoes
- Standing shifts on smooth floors
Not a good fit for
- Half sizes
- Heavy daily mileage
- Wet, rough ground
- Wide feet without sizing up
- Anyone avoiding wool, since the listing names a wool lining
Repeat buying shows up often, and several owners are on their third pair. That is a comfort signal, and it can also be a warning: a third pair is a third manufacturing run.
One long-term customer who buys several Allbirds models each year says the quality has slipped and that they do not last under heavy walking. Other buyers disagree, including one who walked 15,000 to 25,000 steps a day on a trip with no pain.
There are no half sizes and the fit runs slightly small, so several reviewers go up. It has the lowest score of the sneakers we kept apart from the Vivobarefoot, at 4.3 from 777 ratings.
Verdict
Allbirds Tree Runner
Choose it if
Comfort at low weight matters most and your use is moderate.
Skip it if
You walk many miles each week on rough ground and want one pair to last.
Based on the brand’s product details, the Amazon listing and Amazon customer reviews, checked in November 2026.
A Slip-On That Names Its Recycled Share

Our pick · Hemp slip-on
Sanuk Hemp Slip-On
A number is what sets this listing apart. It gives 53% recycled content for the sponge rubber outsole, which is the kind of qualified claim shoppers should look for.
The upper is a hemp and cotton blend with elastic panels, and the footbed is foam. “Responsibly sourced cotton” is the brand’s own phrase, with no certificate named.
Good fit for
- Beach towns and warm errands
- Slipping on without bending down
- Wider toes
- Light wear around home
- Avoiding leather
Not a good fit for
- Rain
- Running or long hikes
- Crushing the heel down to step in
- Named certificates
Few options here get so many happy buyers: 4.7 from 11,086 ratings, the top score in this list. People describe a soft, sand-like underfoot feel and a shoe they buy again.
The listing itself says it runs half a size small, and one repeat buyer found a recent pair tighter than an earlier one. A woman who wants a wider fit buys the men’s version.
Getting in takes a moment. One owner finds them a little hard to slip on until they break in, and another uses a finger at the back when stepping in, so the heel does not get crushed.
Verdict
Sanuk Hemp
Choose it if
You want an easy summer shoe in a natural-fibre blend, and you do not need a certificate.
Skip it if
You need a named certificate before you trust a cotton claim.
Based on the brand’s product details, the Amazon listing and Amazon customer reviews, checked in November 2026.
Less Shoe, and the Most Detailed Recycled Numbers

Our pick · Minimal build
Vivobarefoot Men’s Primus Lite Knit
A thin sole and a light build mean less foam under the foot. Vivobarefoot’s page lists an upper of 85% recycled PET and 15% elastane, laces of 100% recycled PET, and a 98% recycled foam insole.
The outsole is 100% synthetic rubber. Amazon’s listing only says PET mesh, so these numbers may describe a newer version. The brand also lists replaceable laces and insoles, repairs and a take-back.
Good fit for
- Experienced barefoot-shoe wearers
- Wide toes
- Buyers who read material percentages
- Gym work
- Using a brand repair service
Not a good fit for
- A first barefoot shoe worn all day
- Anyone who needs cushioning
- Exact sizing online
- Rough use right away
This is the weakest rating in the group, at 4.0 from 388. We kept it because its materials are the most fully stated, and because it shows that good numbers do not settle the question.
Durability divides buyers. Two reviews report the shoe coming apart early, one within days and one at the sides after light use. Against that, one owner is on a fourth pair and calls it their everyday shoe.
Expect some fit work. Reviewers say it runs long, with one finding the size almost an inch too long, and another felt it rub the top of the foot for two weeks.
A thin sole also feels very different from a cushioned shoe, so many people start with short wears.
Verdict
Vivobarefoot Primus
Choose it if
You already wear barefoot shoes and want the clearest recycled figures in this group.
Skip it if
Long life matters to you more than the material list, given the reports of peeling.
Based on the brand’s product details, the Amazon listing and Amazon customer reviews, checked in November 2026.
A Simple Recycled Canvas Shoe for Light Use

Our pick · Light canvas
TOMS Women’s Alpargata, Recycled Cotton Canvas
People often read “recycled cotton canvas” as all recycled. The bullets say 50% recycled cotton for the upper, lining and sock liner, and that the insole has 50% “eco content”.
Credit TOMS for showing that split: 25% recycled PU foam, 15% recycled rubber and 10% bio oil. The outsole is TPR, a thermoplastic rubber, bonded directly to the upper.
Good fit for
- Warm days and casual outfits
- Short work shifts on flat floors
- Simple styling
- Keeping shoes light for travel
Not a good fit for
- Wet weather
- Long walks and rough ground
- Narrow feet in a snug forefoot
- Bare feet in a tight size
Sizing decides much of the feedback. One buyer wearing their normal size got blisters at the heels and says they needed half a size up, while another found the fit right but tight across the forefoot.
Canvas shoes like this are not built for long lives. A long-time fan describes the cushioning going flat with use, then says they still love them until they wear out, and that sums up the trade. A work-shift buyer says their feet felt better than in their earlier shoes.
Ratings stand at 4.5 from 1,311. Some reviews date from 2014, before this listing’s 2019 date, so the pool is shared with older versions.
Verdict
TOMS Alpargata
Choose it if
You need a light casual shoe and you will not ask it to handle hard wear.
Skip it if
You want a pair to survive several years of daily walking.
Based on the brand’s product details, the Amazon listing and Amazon customer reviews, checked in November 2026.
A Washable Loafer Made From Plastic Bottles

Our pick · Smart casual
Rothy’s Women’s Daily Driver
Most sustainable shoes look casual, so this fills a gap. It is a knit loafer for work clothes, and the thread is made from recycled plastic bottles, according to the listing.
No percentage for recycled content appears in the part of the page we read. Being knit polyester, it also sheds fibres in the wash like other synthetics, and the listing advises cold water and air drying.
Good fit for
- Office wear without leather
- Machine washing rather than replacing
- Sockless wear
- Dressing up or down
- Sitting and standing more than walking
Not a good fit for
- A walking commute before break-in
- Natural fibres only
- Tight budgets
- A long, proven record
Most feedback is about comfort and looks. Owners like wearing them all day and throwing them in the wash, and one couple bought a pair each. One buyer went up half a size, while others call the fit true.
The serious warning comes from a commuter. A one-star review describes open blisters ten minutes into a twenty-minute walk, even after trying two sizes. It is one report, but it is specific enough to plan for.
At 165 ratings for 4.4 stars, and a first listing date of January 2026, this is the youngest record we kept. Long-term durability cannot be judged yet.
Verdict
Rothy’s Daily Driver
Choose it if
You need something smart for work and want to avoid leather.
Skip it if
You walk to the office and cannot risk a slow break-in.
Based on the brand’s product details, the Amazon listing and Amazon customer reviews, checked in November 2026.
How the Eight Compare
| Pair | Main upper | Sole or footbed | Number stated | Ratings | Skip it if |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Teva Hurricane XLT2 | Recycled polyester webbing | EVA footbed, rubber outsole | None | 4.5 from 11,228 | You need a closed shoe |
| Birkenstock Arizona | Suede, leather or Birko-Flor | Cork and latex, EVA outsole | None | 4.5 from 27,290 | You avoid leather and synthetics |
| Veja Esplar | Calfskin, part-recycled lining | Amazonian, recycled rubber and rice waste | Brand: 50% of its soles | 4.4 from 178 | You want soft cushioning |
| Allbirds Tree Runner | Lyocell and recycled polyester | Sugarcane-based EVA | None on what we read | 4.3 from 777 | You walk long distances |
| Sanuk Hemp | Hemp and cotton blend | Foam footbed, part-recycled rubber | 53% recycled outsole | 4.7 from 11,086 | You want a named certificate |
| Vivobarefoot Primus | Recycled PET and elastane | Recycled foam insole, synthetic rubber | Brand: 85% and 98% recycled | 4.0 from 388 | You are new to thin soles |
| TOMS Alpargata | Part-recycled cotton canvas | Part-recycled insole, TPR outsole | 50% recycled cotton | 4.5 from 1,311 | You need long life |
| Rothy’s Daily Driver | Recycled polyester knit | Rubber outsole | None on what we read | 4.4 from 165 | You walk to work |
To cut this down quickly, start with where you will wear them. Warm climates point to the two sandals. An office rules out most of the list except the Veja and the Rothy’s. Then remove anything your values exclude, such as leather or synthetics, and compare only what remains.
Sustainable Shoes for Men and Women
The Amazon listings we read are sold by cut, so check which one you are buying. Materials and sizes can differ between versions of the same shoe.
For Men
Four of the eight are men’s listings. The Teva Hurricane XLT2 suits warm weather, and the Veja Esplar suits a casual office if you accept leather. The Allbirds Tree Runner is the light choice for moderate walking, and the Vivobarefoot Primus Lite Knit is for people who already like thin soles.
For Women
Two are women’s listings: the TOMS Alpargata for light casual wear, and the Rothy’s Daily Driver for smart work outfits without leather. That is a narrower choice. If you want a women’s sandal or sneaker, look for a women’s version of a men’s pick above and read its materials before buying, because we did not review those listings separately.
For the Birkenstock Arizona and the Sanuk Hemp, check the size chart on the listing you choose. One woman who wanted a wider fit buys the men’s Sanuk.
If You Want Sneakers
Start with the Veja Esplar and the Allbirds Tree Runner. The Veja gives more detail about its sole and supply, but its upper is calfskin and it needs a break-in. The Allbirds has no leather upper and is lighter, but buyers disagree about how long it lasts under heavy walking.
What the Labels on a Shoe Can and Cannot Prove
Myth vs Fact
Myth
A shoe sold as “eco-friendly” has been shown to have a low overall impact.
Fact
Broad words like “eco-friendly” are hard to back up. The FTC advises sellers to tie a claim to a specific benefit, and to state the percentage when a product is only partly recycled.
Leather needs its own check. The Leather Working Group standard audits leather manufacturing facilities on areas such as chemical management, water, effluent and traceability. It covers the tannery, so it does not rate the finished shoe. Veja itself says it still has work to do on its leather supply, and that is a more useful statement than a broad green claim.
Natural fibres have trade-offs too, as natural and synthetic fabrics show. Hemp and lyocell avoid petroleum in the fibre, while recycled polyester keeps bottles in use and still sheds in the wash, which is the subject of microplastics from clothing. Our overview of textile certification labels covers the fabric side, and few shoe listings name such a label at all.
Getting More Years From Any Pair
Let a pair dry fully between wears, and follow the care label, because only some of these pairs are sold as machine washable. Replace insoles and laces when the brand sells them. Closed shoes also depend on what you wear inside them, and organic cotton socks are one low-cost part of that. Water-repellent finishes deserve a question too. The issue we raise with PFAS-free rain jackets and sustainable winter coats can apply to outdoor shoes, and these listings do not address it.
A cobbler can often resole leather shoes with a stitched or replaceable sole, but sneakers with a bonded foam sole are much harder to repair. Ask before you buy if repair matters to you. When a pair is done, check for a brand take-back programme, as Vivobarefoot offers, before putting it in the trash.
What We Left Out
KEEN Newport H2 sandals have a very large record, 4.5 from 32,948 ratings, and owners report good durability. We left them out because the listing we read gives no recycled or material percentages to check.
We also passed on Cariuma, because the pairs we found had only about 20 ratings. Its record may grow. Native Shoes’ Jefferson appeared mostly in children’s sizes, and children outgrow shoes on a very different timeline, so it did not fit this list.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a shoe sustainable?
No single label settles it. We look for stated materials in every part, lower-impact or recycled inputs with a percentage, evidence of a long useful life, and options for repair. A shoe you wear for years usually matters more than one recycled part.
Are vegan shoes more sustainable than leather?
Not automatically. Vegan shoes avoid animal material, but many use synthetic uppers and foams. Leather avoids some of that and raises different issues, including cattle farming and tanning. Decide by your values, then compare how long each pair is likely to last.
Can you recycle old shoes?
It is difficult, because a pair combines many bonded materials. Some brands take shoes back, so check first. Donating a wearable pair keeps it in use, and worn-out pairs usually need a dedicated collection scheme.
Are recycled plastic shoes bad for microplastics?
They can shed fibres like other polyester items, especially if you wash them. Recycling the plastic does not change that. Wash them only when needed, and on a cold, gentle cycle if the label allows it.
Do any of these shoes have a certificate?
We did not see a shoe-level certificate such as GOTS named in the parts of these Amazon listings we read. Veja reports Gold-rated tanneries and Teva names the REPREVE yarn, and those cover parts of the supply, not the finished pair.
What are the best sustainable shoes for men?
It depends on where you will wear them. From the men’s listings we read, the Teva Hurricane XLT2 has the strongest durability reports for warm weather, the Veja Esplar suits a casual office, and the Allbirds Tree Runner is lighter for moderate walking.
What are the best sustainable shoes for women?
We reviewed two women’s listings. The TOMS Alpargata suits light casual wear, and the Rothy’s Daily Driver suits smart work outfits without leather. Neither is a strong choice for long walks, and the Rothy’s has a short review record so far.
Should I replace my current shoes with a sustainable pair?
Not while your current pair still works. Wear it until it no longer protects your feet, and repair it if you can. Use this list when you actually need the next pair.
Final Thoughts
Start with the shoe you will wear most. For warm weather, the durability record favours the Teva. For a closed everyday shoe, the Veja gives the clearest supply story if you accept leather and a break-in, and the Allbirds is lighter if your use is moderate.
On the wider question of materials and chemicals in what you wear, begin with what makes clothing eco-friendly. The clothing label evaluator can help with fabric labels, although it was built for clothing, not footwear.

Hassan explores the systems behind everyday sustainability, helping readers understand how materials, products, and everyday choices affect people and the planet. He founded Perfectly Sustainable to make complex sustainability topics clearer, more practical, and easier to act on.
Learn More →
